Introduction:
Ethical dilemmas are situations where we’re forced to choose between two or more conflicting values, principles, or loyalties. We may encounter them both personally & professionally, and how we handle them can have significant consequences. Let us explore some real-life scenarios of ethical dilemmas at workplace and guidance on how to navigate them.
Example 1: Confidentiality vs. Honesty:
As a manager, you discover that an employee is falsifying their timesheets. However, the employee confides in you that they’re struggling financially and need the extra hours to make ends meet. Do you:
– Keep the employee’s secret and risk compromising your integrity and the company’s policies?
– Report the fraud and potentially exacerbate the employee’s financial struggles?
Handling it:
- Consider the context and potential consequences of your actions.
- Explore alternative solutions, such as offering support or resources to help the employee manage their finances.
- Prioritize honesty and transparency while also showing empathy and understanding.
Example 2: Personal Beliefs vs. Professional Obligations
As a healthcare provider, you’re asked to perform a procedure that goes against your personal beliefs. Do you:
– Refuse to perform the procedure and risk compromising patient care?
– Perform the procedure and compromise your personal values?
Handling it:
- Seek guidance from colleagues or mentors.
- Consider the patient’s needs and well-being.
- Explore alternative solutions, such as referring the patient to another provider.
Example 3: Loyalty vs. Whistleblowing
You learn that your business is involved in unethical activities that could have a negative impact on the environment. Do you:
– Keep quiet and maintain your loyalty to the company?
– Speak out and risk facing retaliation or damaging your professional reputation?
Handling it:
- Consider the potential consequences of your actions.
- Seek support from colleagues or external organizations.
- Prioritize your personal values and the greater good
Example 4: Friendship vs. Professionalism
A close friend and colleague is struggling with their workload and asks you to cover for them. However, doing so would require you to bend the rules and compromise your own workload. Do you:
– Help your friend and risk compromising your own professionalism?
– Prioritize your own workload and risk straining your friendship?
Handling it:
- Consider the severity of your friend’s workload struggle and the potential consequences of not helping.
- Evaluate the impact on your own workload and professionalism if you were to help.
- Think about alternative solutions that might benefit both parties.
Example 5: Personal Gain vs. Company Interests
You’re a sales representative and have the opportunity to secure a lucrative deal that would significantly boost your commission. However, the deal would require you to compromise on the company’s quality standards. Do you:
– Prioritize your personal gain and risk compromising the company’s reputation?
– Uphold the company’s quality standards and potentially miss out on the deal?
Handling it:
- Consider the potential damage to the company’s reputation and customer trust if you compromise on quality standards.
- Reflect on your own values and whether prioritizing personal gain over company interests aligns with your principles.
- Explore options that meet both your sales targets and the company’s quality standards.
Conclusion:
If all the above solutions of handling ethical dilemmas do not suffice, think about the consequences of your action being reported to the HR or the ethics committee. Ethical dilemmas can be challenging, but by considering the context, exploring alternative solutions, and prioritizing our values and principles, we can navigate them with integrity and confidence. Ethical leadership is about making tough choices and standing by our principles, even when it’s difficult.
Please reach out to us for any queries on Importance of Business Ethics and Code of Conduct.
For more blogs and articles, visit our official website. Contact us for workshops and queries related to POSH, EAP (Employee Assistance Program,) and Diversity and Inclusion.
